Sweets and treats from the Pie Store.
The Pie Store, located at 100 Watchung Ave. in Upper Montclair, has been serving the best pies, treats and other British delicacies in Montclair for residents to enjoy. The store, inspired by the British, not only has actual groceries imported from the United Kingdom, but is decorated with a bright red door and an assembly line of little British flags hanging from the roof and flowers for a warm welcome. The Pie Store offers food of all kinds whether sweet, savory or both.
“I love The Pie Store because there is nothing else like it around, and I’m not just talking the Montclair community,” said Mark McHenry. “My wife and I drive a half hour whenever we are craving some pies from here. They sure know how to hit the spot.”
On The Pie Store menu, food ranges from savory meat pies to sweet desserts that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. If you’re craving something savory, The Pie Store has an assortment of – I bet you can guess it – pies! But not just regular sweet pies like blueberry crumb or apple pie.
At The Pie Store, they pride themselves on creating delicious and savory pies to make any hungry belly full. Some of the pies that they offer are: cheese, potato and onion pie; Shepherd’s pie; chicken and mushroom pie; steak, ale and mushroom pie; turkey and stuffing pie; chicken tikka pie and more. They also offer steak and kidney pie and bangers and mash pie seasonally. Other than just pies, The Pie Store also offers pocket pasties, cornish pasty, sweet potato, blue cheese and onion pasty, sausage rolls, extra sharp cheddar scones and more.
After downing a few slices of pie, The Pie Store has got your dessert covered. They offer a large variety of pies including apple pie, plum apple pie, raspberry blackberry apple pie, key lime pie, coconut custard pie and Portuguese egg custard tarts. They also offer chocolate mousse pie and banoffee on the weekends as well as scones seasonally.
The special thing about this place is that they offer a Christmas menu around the merry holiday season. More information about their Christmas menu can be found on their website at thepiestorenj.com.
The Pie Store is open Monday through Friday from 10 a.m. to 7 p.m., Saturday from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. and Sunday from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. If you are interested in indulging on a warm meat pie or an entree that caught your attention on the menu, visit their location at 100 Watchung Ave. You can also learn more about The Pie Store by visiting their website or calling them at (973)744-4424.